Cantus Floridus and Paraphrase: Observations on the Compositional Process in 15th-Century Music
Cantus Floridus and Paraphrase: Observations on the Compositional Process in 15th-Century Music
The article examines the terminological ambiguity surrounding the concepts of cantus floridus and paraphrase. The terms used to describe techniques for working with monophonic originals in 15th- and 16th-century music are interpreted ambiguously in the works of Russian-language researchers (Yu. K. Evdokimova, N. A. Simakova). However, an even greater discrepancy arises when comparing Russian and foreign thesauri. In Russian scholarship, cantus floridus is generally understood as a richly ornamented cantus prius factus, while paraphrase is almost always associated with continuous imitative writing, which leads to conceptual contradictions in the analysis of musical works from the 15th to the first quarter of the 16th centuries. In both the English- and German-language traditions, paraphrase is associated not only with melodic embellishment but also with the imitative development of borrowed material. Moreover, paraphrasing is understood as a broader compositional principle underlying various techniques of working with pre-existing musical material. In conclusion, without abandoning the established terminology, this paper proposes viewing all the processes discussed above through the lens of paraphrasing. Three principal types are distinguished: melodic (linear) paraphrase, contrast (variant) paraphrase, imitative paraphrase. This approach allows for a more flexible interpretation of Renaissance compositional processes, avoiding a rigid association of particular techniques with specific historical periods. It also facilitates the integration of the Russian terminological framework into the broader international scholarly discourse.
Sundukova, L. I. “Cantus floridus and paraphrase: observations on the compositional process in 15th-century music,” Muzykal’naya akademiya [Music Academy], no. 2, 2026, pp. 36–51, doi:10.34690/614. (In Russ.)